Post Holdings (POST)·Q1 2026 Earnings Summary
Post Holdings Crushes Q1 as Foodservice Strength Drives 28% EPS Beat and Guidance Raise
February 6, 2026 · by Fintool AI Agent
Post Holdings delivered a blowout Q1 FY2026 with adjusted EPS of $2.13 crushing consensus estimates of $1.67 by 28%. The consumer packaged goods company raised full-year EBITDA guidance to $1,550-1,580M from $1,500-1,540M, reflecting strength in its foodservice business and improved cereal category trends. The stock surged 11% to $115.58 on the news, hitting near its 52-week high.
Did Post Holdings Beat Earnings?
Post delivered a clean triple beat across all key metrics:
Values retrieved from S&P Global
This marks nine consecutive quarters of EPS beats for Post Holdings. The magnitude of the Q1 beat was the largest in recent history, driven primarily by foodservice outperformance and favorable timing benefits.
Ask Fintool AI AgentWhat Did Management Guide?
Management raised FY2026 adjusted EBITDA guidance meaningfully:
The raise reflects three factors:
- Q1 EBITDA upside — $32M above consensus that flows through to full year
- Higher foodservice normalized run rate — Management reset baseline expectations higher
- 8th Avenue integration — Pasta business sale closed Dec 1, 2025; remaining business contributing synergies
CFO Matt Mainer noted the balance of the portfolio outlook is "pretty similar to our initial expectations" with no material changes beyond the foodservice improvement.
What Changed From Last Quarter?
Several notable shifts emerged in Q1:
Cereal Category Stabilizing — The category returned to "more historical down low single-digit pace" from steeper declines previously. COO Nico Catoggio attributed this to SNAP benefit changes and consumer trade-down: "It is very recent... there's a significant change in trajectory that happened in November, December."
Foodservice Run Rate Reset — Management raised the normalized quarterly EBITDA run rate for foodservice to ~$125M, reflecting the structural strength of the value-added egg business. CFO Mainer: "We're back to a more normalized supply and demand dynamic" after Avian Influenza disruptions cleared.
Aggressive Buybacks — Post repurchased 3.7M shares for $378.9M at $101.57/share in Q1, plus another 1.8M shares for $175.4M post-quarter. A new $500M authorization was approved, effective February 7, 2026.
8th Avenue Pasta Sale Closed — The divestiture completed December 1, 2025, simplifying the portfolio.
How Did the Stock React?
POST shares surged +10.7% to $115.58 on the earnings release, trading near the 52-week high of $119.85. Key trading stats:
The magnitude of the move reflects the combination of beat + raise + aggressive capital returns. POST has outperformed the S&P 500 over the trailing 12 months.
Segment Performance
Foodservice (Eggs)
The clear standout. Volume benefited from: (1) customer inventory reload completion after Q4 AI impacts, (2) strong value-added egg demand, and (3) normalized supply/demand dynamics. Management sees 3-4% volume growth with mix benefit as the sustainable algorithm.
Post Consumer Brands (Cereal)
Dollar market share flat YoY despite lower promotional spend. Management deliberately reduced promotions while adjusting assortment. Two cereal facilities closed successfully; savings will flow through in Q3/Q4.
Refrigerated Retail
Q1 is seasonally the strongest quarter due to holiday demand. Private label side dishes (mashed potatoes, mac & cheese) off to a "good early start" in two customers. Easter benefit expected in Q2 before normal seasonal step-down.
Pet
Volume sequentially improving, though still behind category on Nutrish. Management tested lower price points that will be rolled into the brand relaunch with new Price Pack Architecture. Dog category softer than cat.
Ask Fintool AI AgentKey Management Quotes
On cereal category stabilization:
"It is very recent, so there's a significant change in trajectory that happened in November, December, and that coincides with SNAP. So we see it as an outcome of changes in SNAP, and trade down from other categories to cereal." — Nico Catoggio, COO
On foodservice durability:
"We feel good about that run rate and the stickiness of it... the same dynamics of helping operators take labor out of their system. Those are all in the right spot and make economic sense for operators." — Matt Mainer, CFO
On M&A appetite:
"As multiples come down, the M&A becomes a much more interesting measure." — Rob Vitale, CEO
Financial Trends (8 Quarters)
EBITDA and margin data retrieved from S&P Global.
Risks and Concerns
Leverage Remains Elevated — Net debt stands at $7.2B with total debt of $7.5B. Management held net leverage flat despite buybacks.
Pet Segment Challenges — Nutrish brand still struggling; relaunch needed. Private label pet overlapping distribution losses.
RTD Shakes Execution — The ready-to-drink shake plant continues to face "challenges around cost and efficiency" and is "still not at our run rate."
Cereal Category Secular Decline — While stabilizing, the category still trends negative. Management is investing in protein, granola, and fiber innovation.
Forward Catalysts
- Q2 FY26 Earnings — Expected May 2026
- Pet Relaunch — Nutrish brand refresh with new price points
- Cereal Facility Savings — Cost savings from two plant closures to hit P&L in Q3/Q4
- Share Repurchases — $500M new authorization begins February 7, 2026
- Potential M&A — CEO Vitale noted valuations becoming "much more interesting"
Ask Fintool AI Agent